Skip to main content
International Tax

US Expat Taxes in Italy: How to File and Avoid Double Tax

How Americans in Italy file both an Italian and US return, choose between the FEIE and Foreign Tax Credit, and avoid double taxation on income and pensions.

Clark Shi, CPA, founder of TS CPA

Founder, TS CPA

Americans who move to Italy for a job posting, a marriage, or a slower pace of life quickly discover that two governments are now watching their income: the Agenzia delle Entrate in Italy and the IRS back home. US expat taxes in Italy are not optional and they are not automatic. Because Italy taxes its residents on worldwide income and the United States taxes its citizens and green card holders no matter where they live, an American living in Italy typically owes a filing obligation in both countries every year, and the entire planning exercise is about coordinating the two so the same income is never taxed twice.

Do US Citizens Living in Italy Have to File Both Italian and US Tax Returns?

Yes, in almost every case. Italy taxes its tax residents on worldwide income through the Agenzia delle Entrate. From 2024, you are tax resident if, for most of the tax year, you are physically present in Italy (183 days, or 184 in a leap year, counting part days), have your habitual residence there, or have your domicile there, meaning your personal and family life is centered in Italy. Registration in the Anagrafe civil registry creates a presumption of residence that you can rebut with evidence. Any one of these tests is enough. The United States separately taxes its citizens and green card holders on worldwide income no matter where they live, a rule that has nothing to do with Italian residency and everything to do with US citizenship or immigration status.

That means the two filing obligations run independently of each other. Filing and paying tax in Italy does not excuse you from filing a US Form 1040, and filing a US return does not excuse you from your Italian obligations. The mechanisms that keep the same dollar of income from being taxed twice, the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion, the Foreign Tax Credit, and the US-Italy tax treaty, operate on the US side of that equation, not as a substitute for either filing.

How Does Italy Tax Residents on Worldwide Income?

Italy applies its national income tax, the IRPEF, on a worldwide basis to anyone who qualifies as a tax resident, layered with regional and municipal surtaxes set locally on top of the national brackets. Employers generally withhold tax directly from wages throughout the year, similar to US payroll withholding.

Beyond the ordinary IRPEF system, Italy has built several targeted regimes to attract new residents, without needing exact figures to plan around them at a high level. These include a flat-tax option on foreign-source income aimed at qualifying high-net-worth new residents, an inbound-worker regime, commonly called the regime impatriati, that reduces taxable income for people relocating their employment to Italy, and a favorable flat regime for foreign pensioners who move to certain southern regions. Each of these carries its own eligibility rules and thresholds that change periodically, so the current-year rules have to be confirmed before relying on any of them. Italy also levies its own wealth-type taxes, IVAFE on financial assets held abroad and IVIE on real estate held abroad, on Italian tax residents, which matters for an American in Italy who still holds US brokerage accounts or a US home.

Should You Claim the FEIE or the Foreign Tax Credit on Italian Income?

For most Americans earning wages in Italy, the Foreign Tax Credit on Form 1116 is the stronger tool, because Italian income tax, including the national IRPEF plus regional and municipal surtaxes, is generally comparable to or higher than the equivalent US federal tax on the same income. When that is true, the credit can eliminate US tax on your Italian-source income entirely and still leave unused credit on the table.

The Foreign Earned Income Exclusion on Form 2555 works differently: it excludes foreign earned income up to an annually indexed maximum, for example $132,900 for 2026 ($130,000 for 2025; $137,300 for 2027), from US taxable income in the first place under IRC §911. That can be simpler for income under the cap, but it comes with real costs. The FEIE does nothing for self-employment tax, claiming it disqualifies the refundable Additional Child Tax Credit for a family with kids, and once you revoke the election you generally cannot re-elect it for five years without IRS consent. The Foreign Tax Credit, by contrast, is computed by category under IRC §§901 and 904, and any credit you cannot use in the current year carries back one year and forward ten years on Schedule B of Form 1116, which you can use in a future year when your Italian tax falls below the Form 1116 limit, for example a year when one of the special regimes described above lowers your effective Italian rate and leaves unused limitation to absorb the carryover. Our FEIE versus Foreign Tax Credit comparison walks through the decision in more detail, and the two elections can also be combined across different income types in the same year.

Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (Form 2555)
Foreign Tax Credit (Form 1116)
What it does
Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (Form 2555): Excludes foreign earned income up to the annual limit
Foreign Tax Credit (Form 1116): Credits Italian income tax paid against US tax, dollar for dollar
Best fit when
Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (Form 2555): Italian tax is lower than US tax, or income is under the exclusion cap
Foreign Tax Credit (Form 1116): Italian tax is comparable to or higher than US tax, common for ordinary employment income
Effect on Child Tax Credit
Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (Form 2555): Disqualifies the refundable Additional Child Tax Credit
Foreign Tax Credit (Form 1116): Generally preserves eligibility for the refundable Additional Child Tax Credit
Unused benefit
Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (Form 2555): Lost entirely if not used, no carryover
Foreign Tax Credit (Form 1116): Excess credit carries back 1 year and forward 10 years
Effect on self-employment tax
Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (Form 2555): Does not reduce it
Foreign Tax Credit (Form 1116): Does not reduce it

What Does the US-Italy Tax Treaty Do for Double Taxation?

The United States and Italy have a comprehensive income tax treaty, signed in 1999 and in force since 2009, but for most Americans on the ground in Italy the treaty is not where the day-to-day double-tax relief comes from. Like nearly every US treaty, it contains a standard saving clause that lets the United States tax its citizens, and residents whom the treaty's tie-breaker rules treat as US residents, largely as if the treaty did not exist, so the domestic Foreign Tax Credit and Foreign Earned Income Exclusion mechanisms described above do most of the actual work of avoiding double taxation on wages.

Where the treaty matters most is in the details: tie-breaker rules for residency when someone could be considered a resident of both countries in the same year, reduced withholding on certain investment income, rules for business profits, and specific provisions touching pensions and social security. US Social Security paid to an American living in Italy stays taxable in the United States unless that person is also an Italian citizen. A dual US-Italian citizen who lives in Italy is taxed on US Social Security only by Italy, under Article 18(2) and Article 1(2) of the Protocol. Because treaty provisions have to be read in their specific text, any position relying on a specific treaty article beyond the general saving-clause framework should be reviewed against the actual treaty language before you file.

Does the US-Italy Totalization Agreement Cover Social Security?

Yes. A totalization agreement between the United States and Italy has been in force since November 1, 1978, making it one of the oldest US totalization agreements, and it exists specifically to stop a worker from paying into both countries' social security systems on the same earnings at the same time. Without it, an American working in Italy could owe both Italian social insurance contributions and US Social Security tax on the same income: FICA for an employee of a US employer, self-employment tax for a self-employed person.

The agreement works by assigning coverage to a single system based on where the work is performed and how long the assignment is expected to last, documented with a certificate of coverage. Depending on the direction of the assignment, the certificate is issued by the Social Security Administration, to keep someone covered under the US system while working temporarily in Italy, or by INPS, Italy's social security institute, to keep someone covered under the Italian system. Self-employed Americans in Italy should not assume US self-employment tax automatically applies; our guide to totalization agreements and self-employment tax abroad covers how the certificate process works.

How Are Italian Pensions and Retirement Accounts Taxed by the US?

Not automatically. Italy offers several distinct retirement vehicles: the statutory pension administered through INPS, and supplementary or private pension funds, including fondi pensione and other individual pension products that Italian workers use to build additional retirement savings. Being tax-favored under Italian law does not, by itself, make any of these tax-deferred for US purposes.

Under IRC Sections 401(a) and 402(b), a foreign employer plan is not a qualified US plan: employer contributions are generally taxable to a US employee when they vest, growth is usually taxed when it is paid out, and highly compensated employees and plans you fund yourself can be taxed on growth each year, unless a specific treaty provision changes the result. The US-Italy treaty does not defer US tax for an American who lives and works in Italy. Articles 18(1) and 18(2) give Italy the right to tax pensions and social security paid to its residents, but the saving clause in Article 1(2) still lets the United States tax its citizens, so an INPS pension or a fondo pensione payout is taxable on your US return with a credit for the Italian tax. The one pension rule that overrides the saving clause, Article 18(6), covers only a worker who was already in a plan in one country before taking a job in the other, such as a 401(k) participant on assignment in Italy. Because the analysis is the same regardless of which country the plan is in, our foreign pension US tax treatment guide walks through the four questions that determine the answer for any foreign plan: whether growth is taxed as it accrues, whether a treaty defers it, what has to be reported, and how distributions are taxed.

Are Italian Investment Funds Taxed as PFICs?

Usually, yes, and this is one of the more expensive surprises for Americans investing through an Italian bank or brokerage. An Italian fondo comune di investimento, a SICAV, or many ETFs domiciled in Italy or elsewhere in the EU typically meet the definition of a passive foreign investment company under IRC Section 1297, with Sections 1291 and 1298 governing the tax treatment. That classification is a matter of US tax law and does not depend on how the fund is taxed inside Italy under its own domestic rules.

Once a fund is a PFIC, the default US tax treatment is punitive: absent a timely election, gains and certain distributions are spread over your holding period, with the current-year share taxed as ordinary income and each earlier year's share taxed at that year's top rate, and hit with an interest charge on top. Each PFIC generally requires its own Form 8621 filing, and the reporting obligation applies even in a year where no tax is actually due (unless all your PFIC holdings total $25,000 or less, $50,000 on a joint return, on the last day of the tax year, you have no QEF or mark-to-market election in effect for that fund, and you had no excess distribution from it or gain on selling it that year). This is one of the clearest reasons Americans in Italy are usually steered toward US-domiciled brokerage accounts and US-based index funds for new investing rather than opening a local fondo or an investment-linked insurance product through an Italian bank.

What Else Do You Have to Report to the IRS?

Beyond the income tax return itself, Italian financial accounts and investments carry their own separate information-reporting obligations that apply whether or not any US tax is owed. These filings are enforced on their own terms, and the penalties for missing them are typically far larger than any tax that would have been due.

The Italy Reporting Stack

Reference
  • FBAR (FinCEN Form 114). Required when the combined balance of your Italian bank, brokerage, and pension-related accounts exceeds $10,000 at any point during the year. See our FBAR filing guide.
  • Form 8938 (FATCA, IRC §6038D). A separate filing threshold, higher for Americans living abroad, that can require you to list the same Italian accounts directly on your federal tax return. See our Form 8938 guide.
  • Form 8621 (PFIC). Generally required for each Italian fondo, SICAV, or other pooled fund that qualifies as a passive foreign investment company. See our PFIC and Form 8621 guide.

Whether you even count as a US tax resident in the first place, if your situation is more complicated than straightforward citizenship, such as a long visit on a work visa before a move became permanent, is a separate question governed by the substantial presence test.

Bottom Line

Living in Italy does not simplify your US tax picture, it adds a second filing system on top of it. The Agenzia delle Entrate and the IRS operate independently, and the tools that prevent double taxation, primarily the Foreign Tax Credit given Italy's generally comparable-to-higher tax rates, along with the treaty's narrower provisions and the totalization agreement for social security, have to be applied deliberately rather than assumed. Pensions, Italian investment funds, and foreign accounts each carry their own reporting rules on top of the income tax analysis, and getting any one of them wrong tends to cost more in penalties than the underlying tax ever would have.

Have questions about US expat taxes in Italy? Contact TS CPA for a free consultation. We respond within the same day.

Official IRS and Government Sources