What Just Changed
On April 27, 2026, the IRS announced a new way for certain taxpayers to extend the time to sue over a disallowed ERC claim. Thousands of small businesses received Letter 105-C or Letter 106-C in 2024 and 2025 telling them their ERC refund was denied, with only two years from the date of the notice to file suit in federal court.
Under IR-2026-58 (April 27, 2026), a taxpayer who is still waiting for the IRS to consider its response to a Letter 105-C or 106-C, and has six months or less left in the two-year period, can sign Form 907, Agreement to Extend the Time to Bring Suit, and upload it with the IRS Document Upload Tool, choosing CP320B from the menu. The extension counts only once the IRS countersigns the form, and both signatures must be in place before the two years run out. The IRS mails Notice CP320B to taxpayers it has identified as eligible, but you may qualify even without one. Requesting Appeals does not extend the two years.
Which Notice Did You Receive?
Three different letters can disallow an ERC claim, and the defense path depends on which one is in your mail. Each one is a form of IRS resolution with its own deadlines and rights.
Notice CP320B is the newest of the three. The IRS sends it to taxpayers it has identified as eligible to extend the time to sue with Form 907. It is an invitation to act, and the extension exists only once both you and the IRS have signed Form 907.
Why So Many Claims Were Denied
The IRS began issuing mass disallowance notices in the second half of 2024. Then the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), signed July 4, 2025, barred any ERC for the third and fourth quarters of 2021 unless the claim was filed by January 31, 2024, and gave the IRS six years to assess ERC for those quarters.
The denial pattern that followed targets four common scenarios:
Late-filed Q3/Q4 2021 claims. Any amended Form 941-X filed after January 31, 2024 for those two quarters is now barred. The IRS rejects them with a Letter 105-C citing the OBBBA cutoff date.
Insufficient government order documentation. Businesses that claimed the partial suspension test must show the specific government order that affected their operations and quantify the impact. Vague references to "the pandemic" or general state advisories no longer pass review.
Gross receipts test miscalculation. The 50% (2020) or 20% (2021) decline must be measured quarter-over-quarter against the comparable 2019 quarter. Many third-party preparers used incorrect comparison periods or aggregated across quarters incorrectly.
Recovery startup business misclassification. The recovery startup business category for Q3/Q4 2021 has narrow requirements that many businesses did not meet. The IRS is aggressively denying claims that relied on this category without proper documentation of the date the business began carrying on a trade or business.
Your Three Defense Paths
Once a claim is disallowed, you have three procedural options. The right choice depends on the strength of your underlying claim, the amount at stake, and how recently the notice was issued.
Path 1: Administrative Appeal to IRS Independent Office of Appeals
The IRS asks you to dispute the disallowance within 30 days, and you can request Appeals any time within the two years. Form 12203, Request for Appeals Review, works for $25,000 or less per period; larger amounts need a formal written protest. The Office of Appeals is independent of the examination function and applies the hazards of litigation standard, meaning they will settle a case if the IRS would likely lose some portion at trial.
This is the cheapest path. There is no filing fee and no court appearance. The downside is that Appeals settles based on litigation risk, so you may not recover the full amount even if your claim was strong.
Path 2: Refund Suit in Federal District Court or Court of Federal Claims
You have two years from the date of the Letter 105-C or 106-C to file a refund suit, or longer if you and the IRS signed a Form 907 extension. District court allows a jury trial, while the Court of Federal Claims is judge-only. Either court reviews the case de novo, meaning the IRS does not get deference for its prior determination.
This is the most expensive path but offers full recovery if you win. Because employment taxes are divisible, the refund-suit payment requirement can often be met by paying the tax for one employee for one quarter.
Path 3: Collection Due Process and Tax Court Review (Limited)
The ERC is a credit against employment taxes, and the IRS does not issue a notice of deficiency for employment taxes, so there is no 90-day Tax Court petition for an ERC denial. If the IRS assesses the tax and moves to collect, a timely Collection Due Process hearing can let you dispute the liability, and the Appeals determination from that hearing can be reviewed by the Tax Court.
What to Do This Week
The defense window closes quickly. If you have any of the three notices on your desk, complete these five steps within the 30 days the IRS asks for.
Emergency Response Checklist
Deadline- Date-stamp the notice. Write the date you received it on the envelope and the letter itself. Photograph both. This protects you if the IRS challenges your timeline.
- Calendar both dates. The 30-day reply the IRS asks for and the two-year refund suit deadline, which Appeals does not extend. Add a 60-day-before-suit reminder so you have time to retain counsel.
- Pull all supporting documentation. Government orders, payroll records by quarter, gross receipts comparisons, healthcare expense allocations, and any prior preparer's workpapers.
- Order your IRS account transcript. Form 4506-T or online at IRS.gov. This shows exactly which quarters were disallowed and the amounts.
- Get a second opinion before responding. Many disallowance notices contain factual errors or apply incorrect law. A CPA or tax attorney experienced in ERC defense can often identify a strong response in the first hour of review.
Common Mistakes That Forfeit the Defense
Three errors regularly cost taxpayers their right to recover.
Do Not Do These Things
Caution- Ignoring the notice. Silence does not preserve your rights. The 30-day reply the IRS asks for and the two-year refund suit window both run from the date on the notice.
- Sending a casual reply. A handwritten note saying "this is wrong" does not constitute a valid protest. Form 12203 (for $25,000 or less per period) or a formal protest letter is required, and the response must address each specific ground for disallowance.
- Missing the two-year date. Appeals does not extend it. Only a signed and countersigned Form 907 does.
If the IRS Already Clawed Back Your Refund
Some businesses received their ERC refund in 2022 or 2023, then received a notice in 2024 or 2025 demanding repayment with interest. This is a different procedural posture from a disallowance of an unpaid claim.
Employment taxes do not go through the notice-of-deficiency process, so there is no 90-day Tax Court letter for an ERC recapture. You can respond to the IRS notice, request Appeals, and, after paying the divisible part of the tax for at least one employee and one quarter, file a refund claim and then a refund suit.
The IRS may also issue a Final Notice of Intent to Levy. If a levy notice arrives, request a Collection Due Process hearing within 30 days. The CDP request stops most collection action and can give you a forum to dispute the underlying liability if you have not had an earlier chance to do so.
When the Form 907 Extension Applies
Under IR-2026-58 (April 27, 2026), a taxpayer who is still waiting for the IRS to consider its response to a Letter 105-C or 106-C, and has six months or less left in the two-year period, can sign Form 907, Agreement to Extend the Time to Bring Suit, and upload it with the IRS Document Upload Tool, choosing CP320B from the menu. The extension counts only once the IRS countersigns the form, and both signatures must be in place before the two years run out. The IRS mails Notice CP320B to taxpayers it has identified as eligible, but you may qualify even without one. It does not cover disallowances unrelated to a Letter 105-C or 106-C. If you already requested Appeals and know your Appeals Officer, contact that officer about the extension.
What the IRS Looks for in a Successful Defense
Disallowance reversals share a few common elements. Build your response around these proof points where they apply to your business.
Strong ERC Defense Evidence
Strategy- A specific government order (federal, state, county, or city) with effective dates that overlap the quarter you claimed
- Quantified impact of that order on your operations: hours reduced, capacity limited, services suspended, with payroll allocated to affected functions
- Quarter-over-quarter gross receipts schedules comparing to the 2019 baseline, prepared from books contemporaneously with the claim
- Healthcare expense documentation aligned to qualifying wages
- Prior preparer workpapers showing the methodology, especially if you used a third-party ERC mill (their workpapers may help, hurt, or trigger a malpractice claim)
- Affidavits from operations managers describing the specific suspension and its impact
Bottom Line
The IRS is not finished with ERC disallowances. The IR-2026-58 Form 907 route is meaningful, but it needs both signatures before the two years run out, and Appeals is still selective about which cases it will settle. Most successful defenses combine a strong administrative protest with a parallel preparation for refund suit in case Appeals does not produce a satisfactory result.
If you have a Letter 105-C, Letter 106-C, or CP320B on your desk, the worst response is to wait. The best response is to preserve every procedural right, document the underlying claim quickly, and decide on a path while the two-year window is still open.
Our IRS and state tax resolution team can review your disallowance notice and recommend the defense path that fits. Have questions about an ERC disallowance? Contact TS CPA for a free consultation. We respond within the same day.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should you do if your ERC claim was disallowed?
Identify which notice you received (Letter 105-C, Letter 106-C, or CP320B), note the date, and respond. The IRS asks for a reply within 30 days, and you can request Appeals any time within the two years. The strongest defenses combine an administrative protest with parallel preparation for a refund suit in case Appeals does not settle favorably.
How long do you have to challenge a disallowed ERC claim?
A Letter 105-C or 106-C generally gives you two years from the notice date to file suit in district court or the Court of Federal Claims. Under IR-2026-58, a taxpayer still waiting on the IRS with six months or less left can extend that window by signing Form 907. The extension counts only once the IRS countersigns it.
What is the difference between Letter 105-C and Letter 106-C?
Letter 105-C is a full disallowance, meaning the IRS denied your entire ERC claim and issued no refund. Letter 106-C is a partial disallowance, where the IRS approved and refunded part of the claim and denied the rest. Both carry a two-year window to contest the disallowed amount.
Why were so many ERC claims denied?
Many denials cite insufficient evidence of a qualifying government-ordered suspension or the required gross receipts decline, often tied to aggressive promoter-prepared claims. Strong documentation of the specific suspension orders and quarter-by-quarter revenue is central to a successful defense.
Can you still defend an ERC claim after the IRS clawed back the refund?
Yes. Even after a recapture, you can pursue an administrative protest through the IRS Independent Office of Appeals, a Collection Due Process hearing if the IRS moves to levy, and, if necessary, a refund suit. The key is acting quickly to preserve deadlines and assembling the underlying eligibility documentation.

